1. Home
  2. BMW
  3. M4
  4. Years compared

BMW M4: which year to buy? Recalls and complaints by year

Of 13 model years of the BMW M4 on record, 2016 has the most owner complaints at NHTSA (22, most often about engine). 2017 has the most recall campaigns (3).

How to read this

Each row counts what official sources have on record for that model year: recall campaigns and owner complaints filed with NHTSA, and how many of those complaints mention a crash, a fire or an injury. We do not rate reliability. Fewer complaints can also mean fewer cars sold or a newer car, so open the year before you decide. 🇺🇸 Local data

Year Recalls Complaints Crash, fire or injury Most reported Combined
2027 0 0 0 — 19 MPG
2026 0 0 0 — 19 MPG
2025 0 0 0 — 18 MPG
2024 0 0 0 — 19 MPG
2023 0 0 0 — 18 MPG
2022 0 2 0 VISIBILITY 19 MPG
2021 2 1 0 SERVICE BRAKES 19 MPG
2020 2 1 0 SUSPENSION 19 MPG
2019 0 0 0 — 19 MPG
2018 1 6 0 FUEL/PROPULSION SYSTEM 20 MPG
2017 3 2 0 POWER TRAIN 19 MPG
2016 3 22 2 ENGINE 19 MPG
2015 3 12 1 ENGINE 19 MPG

Recalls: NHTSA campaigns only, so a defect also recalled in Canada is not counted twice. Stars: NHTSA overall rating. Fuel economy: EPA.

All years of the BMW M4

Questions

Which BMW M4 year has the most complaints?
Of 13 model years of the BMW M4 on record, 2016 has the most owner complaints at NHTSA (22, most often about engine).
Which BMW M4 year has the most recalls?
2017 has the most recall campaigns (3).
Which BMW M4 years have no complaints or recalls on record?
2027, 2026, 2025, 2024, 2023, 2019. That can also mean fewer cars sold or a newer car, not only a better one.
How is this comparison made?
We count, for each model year, the recall campaigns and owner complaints filed with NHTSA, and how many complaints mention a crash, a fire or an injury. We do not rate reliability: raw counts also depend on how many cars were sold and how old they are.